O’Brien’s message

The fiction/ autobiography status of the book really confused me and I was frustrated that O’Brien was not up front about what part was true or false. Although, this frustration still lingers, the interviews we watched and the discussions we had in class has made this frustration easier to cope with. I actually thought O’Brien had a daughter and that all the stories he and his daughter did were factual, so when I discovered he only had sons I was disappointed. Similarly to our discussion in class, O’Brien mentions that the meaning behind each story in the novel is more important than understanding which story is true or false.

In the interview, O’Brien discussed this topic perfectly. I can now appreciate why he wrote this novel the way he did instead of trying to fool and confuse his audience. His goal was to try to “capture the heart, stomach, and back of the throat of readers who can lie in bed at night and participate in a story.” O’Brien knew if he wrote a plain “war story” like those in a magazine, the title would already abstract readers from being interested. To prevent this from happening, he wrote a story which, from his experience, would allow readers to become involved in the story instead of just reading the words. This is why O’Brien enjoys literature and that is what he hoped to give to others: to want to participate in the novel itself. In my opinion, he conquered his goal. With this knowledge, I am able to fully understand the reasoning behind his writing style.

I would continue to call the novel fiction, because I think there is more fiction than fact in the novel, but I no longer think that is a negative thing. Just like Foster ingrained in our minds, writers do what they have to do in order to make their meaning blunt and to tell the readers what they want them to hear and O’Brien used this strategy to his benefit.


5 thoughts on “O’Brien’s message

  1. I agree with how you categorized the work and I totally agree that it was frustrating to try and dig through O’Brien’s intentions. Needless to say, it was more than difficult at first to determine what was intended to teach and what is just there for our entertainment. However, after a while, I stopped caring. That isn’t to say that his experiences meant nothing to me, but I treated all of his stories as lessons, parallels to society, and food for thought. I also think it was really cleaver how, because he blurred the lines between fact and fiction, we as the reader were much closer than we otherwise might have been to experiencing many of the unique and gruesome thoughts that only war offers.


  2. I too was disappointed when we discovered that O’Brien did not have a daughter in real life. I felt denied that a story with such power may not have any relation to historical truth. I concur, TTTC is most definitely best classified as a work of fiction. I enjoyed the ploys O’Brien used to meld the illusion of fact with fiction together such as using a self named character.


  3. Pingback: Other Blogs | shootingforlifeblog

  4. I agree with how frustration occurs when as a reader you can’t decipher fact from fiction, or in this case, truth from storytelling. The way O’Brien organizes his novel forces us to shift our focus from the situation itself to the deep emotion that grows from it and how while the concrete facts fade, our memory will hold onto the feelings created by that moment. Honestly, I think that is how life is. I know from personal experience, when major things have occurred in my life, what I remembered and what was important was not the event itself, but the emotional experience I took away from it.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Pingback: Blogs I Commented On | A Tara-fic Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s